Zuke’s Mini Naturals Dog Training Treats for Dogs, Pet Treats made with Real Beef, 16 oz. Resealable Pouch - 16 oz. Bag

“...My dogs love them and will do anything for a morsel. Unfortunately, they are a limited time treat. But they were wonderful while they lasted!”source

“Great product !!!”source

“These look great, smell great and the dogs love them. They're small so I can give them to the dogs more often like when we're training....”source

“These are the perfect size for training . Valued rewards but not too filling or fattening. My two 10 lb dogs love it when we do training!”source

“...When they are soft, they’re great for training . However, I’m hesitant to give my dogs the treats when they looked dried out and are hard as a rock....”source

“These are perfect for training . They do have a strong smell, which helps when you have a food motivated dog with one heck of a sniffer....”source

“...these beef-flavored dog treats to any pet parent looking for a tasty and motivating reward for their pup....”source

“... Dogs loved the flavor though.”source

“my dog loves these littles treats, they are soft , look tasty, he's in Heaven when he has those. Good training treat as they are small (dime diameter )”source

“...But this last bag, they are hard as a rock and inedible. Tried going thru multiple routes to return or replace, but no can do....”source

“...my dog won’t eat them .”source

“...They’re soft and chewy , which is great for quick training sessions because they’re easy for him to eat without pausing to gnaw....”source

“... Very fresh - product received in October 2021 has an expiration date of July 2023.”source

“Seal on the bag was broken, the treats inside were hard as stone and stale , not usable at all. Turns out this is a non-returnable item....”source